The Best Air Fryer Cheese Toastie | So Tasty!

Are you on the hunt for the perfect cheese toastie recipe that will melt in your mouth and make your taste buds dance with delight? I’ve taken this classic comfort food to a whole new level with our air fryer cheese toastie recipe.

Cheese Toastie In The Air Fryer

This recipe is not just about slapping some cheese between two slices of bread and hoping for the best. Oh no, we’re talking about a golden, crispy exterior with a gooey, cheesy centre that’s so delicious it’ll make you wonder how you ever lived without it.

In this recipe, I’ve added a hint of mustard and garlic powder to bring out the best air fryer toastie you’ve ever tasted!

Crispy Cheese Toastie

But why stop there? I’ve added a few secret ingredients and techniques to elevate this humble sandwich into a culinary masterpiece. The best part? It’s all done using an air fryer, providing a healthier alternative to traditional frying methods while still achieving that unbeatable crunch.

Ingredients

• 2 Slices of Bread
• 1 tbsp Mayonnaise
• ½ tsp Mustard (English preferably or Dijon)
• ¼ tsp Garlic Powder (or granules)
• Butter (to spread)
• Pinch of Ground Black Pepper (optional)

Toastie Fillings Variations

Here are other toastie suggestions you may like to try:

Cheese and Ham Toastie

Cheese and Onion Toastie

Tomato and Cheese Toastie

Cheese, Ham, Tomato and Onion Toastie

Cheese and Smoked Bacon Toastie

How To Make A Grilled Cheese Toastie

• Thinly spread the butter on both slices of bread. This will be for the outside to make it crispy and toastie.
• Add the mayonnaise, garlic powder, pepper, and mustard in a small bowl. Mix together thoroughly. Spread this on the other side of both slices of bread.
• Slice or grate the cheese and place it on one bread slice (on top of the mayo side).
• Sandwich together with the other slice. The buttered sides should be on the outside.
• Place in the air fryer set the temperature to 180℃/355℉, and cook for 6 minutes. Turn over the toastie and cook for another 4 minutes.

What To Serve With A Toastie

A cheese toastie, as comforting and delicious as it is on its own, pairs even better with a range of side dishes. From simple to more complex ideas, there’s no shortage of ways to complement this classic sandwich and turn your meal into a feast.

One of the most traditional and beloved pairings is a steaming bowl of tomato soup. This creamy, tangy delight provides a perfect balance to the richness of the cheese, making each bite even more satisfying.

Salads are another great side dish. A fresh, crisp salad adds a refreshing contrast to the warm, melty cheese toastie. It can be as basic or as creative as you like – think mixed greens with vinaigrette, Caesar salad, or even a tangy coleslaw.

If you’re in the mood for something a bit different, try serving your cheese toastie with some marinara sauce for dipping. The tomato and herb flavours work wonderfully with the cheese, adding an Italian twist to your meal.

For those with a sweet tooth, jam, marmalade, or chutney can surprisingly make a delightful addition. The sweetness beautifully offsets the savoury cheese, creating a unique flavour combination.

FAQ’s